- Daily Update from Securities Docket
- Posts
- Today: Binance and SEC Square Off in TRO Hearing that Could "Effectively End" Binance US
Today: Binance and SEC Square Off in TRO Hearing that Could "Effectively End" Binance US
Plus "regulatory heat" fuels BigLaw revenues in crypto enforcement and litigation practice.
Good morning! Here’s what’s up.
Clips ✂️
A Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) Monday effort to freeze Binance US’s funds is a “draconian and unduly burdensome” move, the U.S. affiliate of the global crypto exchange argued Monday.
“If the Court does address the merits of the SEC’s motion, it should deny that motion. The SEC seeks unnecessary and unjustified relief. Far from requesting relief that is ‘carefully calibrated’ to ‘maintain[] the status quo’ … the SEC’s proposed remedies would effectively end BAM’s business,” Binance. US’s motion argued.
***
Binance and Binance. US had already denied the claims in blog posts and tweets last week, but Monday marked a court-ordered deadline for a formal response. The U.S. District Court for the District of D.C. will hold a hearing on the motion on Tuesday, June 13 at 2:00 p.m. ET.
👉 Defendants Bam Trading Services Inc. and Bam Management US Holdings Inc.’s Opposition To Plaintiff’s Emergency Motion For A Temporary Restraining Order is here.
The Joint Memorandum Of Law On Behalf Of Defendants Binance Holdings Limited And Changpeng Zhao In Opposition To Plaintiff’s Emergency Motion For A Temporary Restraining Order is here.
Big Law Bets on Crypto as Industry Faces More Regulatory Heat
The Securities and Exchange Commission’s recent lawsuits against crypto companies—and the Big Law firms defending them—is the latest indication that the industry will be a growing source of work and revenue for Big Law.
Attorneys in law firm cryptocurrency and securities investigations practices have reported a growing volume of work in advising crypto companies in litigation, enforcement, restructuring, bankruptcy work and lobbying.
“We continue to see robust demand from clients in the crypto industry for regulatory compliance across a variety of disciplines, litigation, and public policy counseling,” said Coy Garrison, a partner in Steptoe & Johnson’s blockchain and cryptocurrency and financial services practices. “We are confident that this industry will not go away and that the implementation of new regulations for this industry will help foster its growth over time.”
Binance US Hires Ex-SEC Enforcement Co-Director Canellos as It Fights Charges
Binance.US added four lawyers from Milbank LLP, including a former co-director of the Securities and Exchange Commission’s enforcement division, George Canellos, as the beleaguered crypto platform prepares its defense against US allegations of operating an illegal securities exchange.
Canellos, who is global head of the litigation and arbitration group at Milbank, previously supervised about 1,300 attorneys at the SEC on investigations including the insider trading actions against Raj Rajaratnam and hedge fund managers associated with S.A.C. Capital. Before then, he was chief of the major crimes unit at the US Attorney’s Office in the Southern District of New York.
Republicans take shot at SEC’s Gensler with proposal to oust him
Republican lawmakers took a shot at the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission Chair Gary Gensler on Monday, announcing proposed legislation that would seek to remove him. But they’d need bi-partisan support for it to pass the Senate.
House Majority Whip Tom Emmer, R-Minn., a longtime proponent of digital assets, joined the introduction of Rep. Warren Davidson’s so-called “SEC Stabilization Act” that aims to restructure the Securities and Exchange Commission and remove Gary Gensler as Chair.
***
The proposed legislation would adjust the commission to include a sixth commissioner, and a single political party would not be able to hold more than three commissioner seats at a given time.
If you spotted a gigantic crypto bubble in the late 2010s and early 2020s, how would you play it? Two obvious wrong answers:
–Short crypto. You’d have gotten carried out, multiple times.
–Long crypto. This is better — the George Soros “When I see a bubble forming, I rush in to buy” approach — but still risky (the bubble did pop) and sort of analytically unsatisfying.
And a pretty good answer:
–Take out absolutely bajillions of dollars of non-recourse loans to buy as much crypto as you can, selling enough along the way — and putting the proceeds somewhere your creditors can’t get them — to make yourself dynastically wealthy. Borrow $1 billion to buy $1 billion worth of crypto. If that turns into $2 billion of crypto, pay off your loans, take the extra $1 billion and bury it in your backyard, and do it again. If you do it again and it turns into $0 of crypto, walk away from your debts, dig up your backyard and buy yachts.
👉 This was Matt Levine’s summary of what Three Arrows Capital did in the crypto space. He adds that “this worked for a while and made the 3AC guys rich, and then it stopped working and made 3AC’s lenders bankrupt. But the 3AC guys took money off the table along the way, and they will be wealthy for the rest of their lives. A bunch of crypto lending platforms had too much money and wanted to do something dumb with it. 3AC provided the dumb thing to do with it, and took a large fee for that service.”
Where are the 3AC founders now? “Living large,” the NYT reports.
The SEC has spoken: The future of finance is not in America
Of the alleged securities violations against Coinbase, the list of assets deemed to be securities reveals the broad nature of its classification. The SEC’s claims that its self-custodied wallet is a broker-dealer because it helps “route” a transaction doesn’t hold much merit either. And alleging that Coinbase is behaving like a clearing agency also seems far-fetched.
These actions are likely to attract fines for Coinbase and possibly the closure of its staking business. But there is a distinct difference between this and the SEC’s legal action against Binance, which faces an outright ban from operating in the U.S. The silver lining to this is that Coinbase now has the opportunity to fight the SEC in court — and fight it will. Armstrong has already said he’ll do what it takes to “get the job done.” The outcome of this case will likely determine the future of crypto in America.
Galaxy Digital’s Termination of $1.2B Acquisition of Crypto Custodian BitGo Upheld by Federal Judge
A federal judge has sided with Galaxy Digital (GLXY.TO) – the crypto merchant bank led by Mike Novogratz – in its decision to terminate its $1.2 billion acquisition of crypto custodian BitGo.
Delaware Chancery Court Vice Cchancellor James Laster ruled last week that Galaxy had a “valid basis” to end the deal because BitGo provided Galaxy with “non-compliant” documents pertaining to its financial health.
“There are no facts alleged that could make it reasonably conceivable that the exercise of the termination right was inconsistent with the implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing,” Judge Laster said in the ruling.
Ex-Goldman Sachs banker stole merger details, prosecutor tells jury
A former Goldman Sachs banker leaked details of potential corporate mergers to a friend who traded on the information, a prosecutor told a New York jury during opening arguments of a trial on Monday.
Former Goldman Sachs Vice President Brijesh Goel faces securities fraud, conspiracy and obstruction of justice charges for allegedly tipping his friend Akshay Niranjan to deals the bank was considering funding in 2017 and 2018.
Prosecutors say Goel gleaned the information on at least six occasions about potential transactions – including Japanese chemical manufacturer Kuraray’s $1.1 billion acquisition of Calgon Carbon Corp – from internal Goldman emails, and then tipped Niranjan over games of squash.
XRP Jumps as Hinman Speech Released in Ripple Labs Filing
XRP prices jumped 7.4% in the past 24 hours to buck nominal gains in the broader crypto market as traders likely bet on a favorable outcome for payments company Ripple Labs in its ongoing Ripple vs SEC lawsuit.
These gains came as documents tied to William Hinman, the former director of the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC)’s Division of Corporation Finance from 2017 to 2020, were released to the public in connection with the SEC’s lawsuit against Ripple Labs.
Ladies and Gentlemen, let’s welcome The Hinman Emails!
— J.W. Verret🛡 (@JWVerret)
12:32 PM • Jun 13, 2023
My biggest take away from these #HinmanEmails is that it seems @SECGov officials who weighed in on the speech believed the goal was to provide market guidance and tried to write it in a way that would convey that. Thus, in the @Ripple case, the SEC lawyers’ argument that the… twitter.com/i/web/status/1…
— Eleanor Terrett (@EleanorTerrett)
12:07 PM • Jun 13, 2023
I looked into this and it doesn't look good for emerging managers:
• The bill won't pass the Senate (3% chance)
• Even if it did, it won't change much3 recs:
• Increase # of LPs per fund
• Allow VC funds to use equity crowdfunding
• Add FoFs as VC— Chris Harvey (@ChrisHarveyEsq)
8:45 PM • Jun 12, 2023
The next 36 hrs will be critical for crypto.
Today 5 pm: @binance files its opposition to SEC's motion for order freezing assets of @binanceUS
Tomorrow 2 pm: Hearing on SEC's motion to freeze assets
Tomorrow (sometime): Release of summary judgment exhibits (including Hinman… twitter.com/i/web/status/1…
— MetaLawMan (@MetaLawMan)
3:54 PM • Jun 12, 2023
Sorry CZ. The UAE won't save you. #Binance
— Not Tiger Global (@NotChaseColeman)
6:50 AM • Jun 12, 2023